梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
Richelieu ��questionable men enough�� had succeeded a Dubois�察�a Rohan�察�a
Lomenie de Brienne�察�a Maury�察�a Talleyrand�察�and at the revolution of 1789
thoughtful Frenchmen asked�察�once and for all�察�what was to be done with a
Church of which these were the hierophants�拭�
Whether these complaints affected the French Church as a ;religious;
institution�察�must depend entirely on the meaning which is attached to the
word ;religion;�此 �that they affected her on scientific�察�rational�察�and moral
grounds�察�independent of any merely political one�察�is as patent as that the
attack based on them was one´sided�察 �virulent�察 �and often somewhat
hypocritical�察 �considering the private morals of many of the assailants。
We knowor ought to knowthat within that religion which seemed to the
61
´ Page 62´
THE ANCIEN REGIME
philosophes ��so distorted and defaced had it become�� a nightmare dream�察�
crushing the life out of mankind�察 �there lie elements divine�察 �eternal�察�
necessary for man in this life and the life to come。 But we are bound to
askHad they a fair chance of knowing what we know�拭 �Have we proof
that their hatred was against all religion�察�or only against that which they
saw around them�拭 �Have we proof that they would have equally hated�察�
had they been in permanent contact with them�察 �creeds more free from
certain faults which seemed to them�察 �in the case of the French Church�察�
ineradicable and inexpiable�拭 �Till then we must have charitywhich is
justiceeven for the philosophes of the eighteenth century。
This view of the case had been surely overlooked by M。 de
Tocqueville�察�when he tried to explain by the fear of revolutions�察�the fact
that both in America and in England�察 �while the boldest political doctrines
of the eighteenth´century philosophers have been adopted�察 �their anti´
religious doctrines have made no way。;
He confesses that�察 �Among the English�察�French irreligious philosophy
had been preached�察�even before the greater part of the French philosophers
were born。 It was Bolingbroke who set up Voltaire。 Throughout the
eighteenth century infidelity had celebrated champions in England。 Able
writers and profound thinkers espoused that cause�察 �but they were never
able to render it triumphant as in France。; Of these facts there can be no
doubt�此 �but the cause which he gives for the failure of infidelity will
surely sound new and strange to those who know the English literature and
history of that century。 It was�察�he says�察 �inasmuch as all those who had
anything to fear from revolutions�察 �eagerly came to the rescue of the
established faith。; Surely there was no talk of revolutions�察 �no wish�察�
expressed or concealed�察�to overthrow either government or society�察�in the
aristocratic clique to whom English infidelity was confined。 Such was�察�at
least�察 �the opinion of Voltaire�察 �who boasted that ;All the works of the
modern philosophers together would never make as much noise in the
world as was made in former days by the disputes of the Cordeliers about
the shape of their sleeves and hoods。; If ��as M。 de Tocqueville says��
Bolingbroke set up Voltaire�察�neither master nor pupil had any more leaning
than Hobbes had toward a democracy which was not dreaded in those days
62
´ Page 63´
THE ANCIEN REGIME
because it had never been heard of。 And if ��as M。 de Tocqueville heartily
allows�� the English apologists of Christianity triumphed�察 �at least for the
time being�察�the cause of their triumph must be sought in the plain fact that
such men as Berkeley�察 �Butler�察 �and Paley�察 �each according to his light�察�
fought the battle fairly�察�on the common ground of reason and philosophy�察�
instead of on that of tradition and authority�察 �and that the forms of
Christianity current in Englandwhether Quaker�察 �Puritan�察 �or Anglican
offended�察 �less than that current in France�察 �the common´sense and the
human instincts of the many�察�or of the sceptics themselves。�А�
But the eighteenth century saw another movement�察 �all the more
powerful�察�perhaps�察�because it was continually changing its shape�察�even its
purpose�察 �and gaining fresh life and fresh adherents with every change。
Propagated at first by men of the school of Locke�察 �it became at last a
protest against the materialism of that school�察�on behalf of all that is�察�or
calls itself�察 �supernatural and mysterious。 Abjuring�察 �and honestly�察 �all
politics�察�it found itself sucked into the political whirlpool in spite of itself�察�
as all human interests which have any life in them must be at last。 It
became an active promoter of the Revolution�察�then it helped to destroy the
Revolution�察�when that had�察�under Napoleon�察�become a levelling despotism�察�
then it helped�察�as actively�察�to keep revolutionary principles alive�察�after the
reaction of 1815��a Protean institution�察�whose power we in England are as
apt to undervalue as the governments of the Continent were apt�察�during the
eighteenth century�察�to exaggerate it。 I mean�察�of course�察�Freemasonry�察�and
the secret societies which�察 �honestly and honourably disowned by
Freemasonry�察 �yet have either copied it�察�or actually sprung out of it。 In
England�察 �Freemasonry never was�察 �it seems�察 �more than a liberal and
respectable benefit´club�察 �for secret societies are needless for any further
purposes�察 �amid free institutions and a free press。 But on the Continent
during the eighteenth century�察 �Freemasonry excited profound suspicion
and fear on the part of statesmen who knew perfectly well their friends
from their foes�察 �and whose precautions were�察 �from their point of view�察�
justified by the results。
I shall not enter into the deep question of the origin of Freemasonry。
One uninitiate�察 �as I am�察 �has no right to give an opinion on the great
63
´ Page 64´