嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
敬響嶄猟利 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

the crisis in russia(躯忽裡字)-及15嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




modifications 

     which�察�as a matter of fact�察�nullified that position altogether。 It was then 



                                               35 


´ Page 36´

                                  THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



about ten at night�察�and the Conference adjourned。                We drove round to the 

prison in sledges�察�and by way of supper had some more soup and potatoes�察�

and so back to the railway station to sleep in the cars。 

       Next day the Conference opened about noon�察�when there was a long 

discussion of the points at issue。           Workman after workman came to the 

platform and gave his view。           Some of the speeches were a little naive�察�as 

when one soldier said that Comrades Lenin and Trotsky had often before 

pointed out difficult roads�察�and that whenever they had been followed they 

had shown the way to victory�察�and that therefore�察�though there was much 

in   the   Central   Committee's   theses   that   was   hard   to   digest�察  �he   was   for 

giving   them   complete   support�察  �confident   that�察  �as   Comrades   Lenin   and 

Trotsky were in favor of them�察�they were likely to be right this time�察�as so 

often    heretofore。     But     for  the   most    part  the   speeches     were    directly 

concerned      with    the  problem   under     discussion�察    �and   showed     a  political 

consciousness which would have been almost incredible three years ago。 

The Red Army served as a text for many�察�who said that the methods which 

had produced that army and its victories over the Whites had been proved 

successful   and   should   be   used   to   produce   a   Red   Army   of   Labor       and 

similar     victories    on   the   bloodless     front    against    economic      disaster。 

Nobody   seemed   to   question   the   main   idea   of   compulsory   labor。          The 

contest that aroused real bitterness was between the methods of individual 

and   collegiate   command。         The   new   proposals   lead   eventually   towards 

individual     command�察      �and   fears   were   expressed     lest  this  should    mean 

putting   summary   powers   into   the   hands        of   bourgeois   specialists�察  �thus 

nullifying ;workers' control;。 In   reply�察�it was   pointed out that   individual 

command had proved necessary in the army and had resulted in victory for 

the    revolution。      The    question     was    not   between     specialists    and    no 

specialists。      Everybody       knew     that   specialists   were     necessary。     The 

question was how to get the most out of them。                Effective political control 

had secured that bourgeois specialists�察�old officers�察�led to victory the army 

of the Red Republic。         The same result could be secured in the factories in 

the same way。        It was pointed out that in one year they had succeeded in 

training 32��000 Red Commanders�察�that is to say�察�officers from the working 

class   itself�察  �and   that   it   was   not   Utopian   to   hope   and   work   for   a   similar 



                                                36 


´ Page 37´

                                   THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



output of 

     workmen        specialists�察   �technically    trained�察   �and   therefore     themselves 

qualified   for   individual   command   in   the   factories。   Meanwhile   there   was 

nothing against the employment of Political Commissars in the factories as 

formerly   in   the   regiments�察  �to   control   in   other   than   technical   matters   the 

doings      of  the   specialists。     On    the   other    hand�察   �it  was   said   that   the 

appointment of Commissars would tend to make Communists unpopular�察�

since inevitably in many cases they would have to support the specialists 

against   the   workmen�察  �and   that   the   collegiate   system   made   the   workmen 

feel    that  they   were    actually    the   masters�察   �and   so   gave   possibilities    of 

enthusiastic   work   not   otherwise   obtainable。           This   last   point   was   hotly 

challenged。       It   was   said   that   collegiate    control    meant    little  in  effect�察�

except waste of time and efficiency�察�because at worst work was delayed by 

disputes      and   at   best   the   workmen       members       of   the   college    merely 

countersigned         the   orders     decided     upon     by    the    specialists。      The 

enthusiastic   work   was   said   to   be   a   fairy   story。   If   it   were   really   to   be 

found then there would be no need for a conference to discover how to get 

it。 

       The most serious opposition�察�or at least the most serious argument put 

forward�察�for there was less opposition than actual discussion�察�came from 

some of the representatives of the Trade Unionists。                  A good deal was said 

about the position of the Trades Unions in a Socialist State。                     There was 

general recognition that since the Trade Unions themselves controlled the 

conditions of labor and wages�察�the whole of their old work of organizing 

strikes against capitalists had ceased to have any meaning�察�since to strike 

now would be   to strike against their own   decisions。                 At the same   time�察�

certain tendencies to Syndicalism were still in existence�察�tendencies which 

might well lead to conflict between different unions�察�so that�察�for example�察�

the match makers or the metal worker�察�might wish to strike a bargain with 

the State�察�as of one country with another�察�and this might easily lead to a 

complete collapse of the socialist system。 

       The   one   thing   on   which   the   speakers   were   in   complete   agreement 

was the absolute need of an effort in industry equal to�察�if not greater than�察�

the effort made in the army。            I thought it significant that in many of the 



                                                 37 


´ Page 38´

                                  THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



speeches the importance of this effort was urged as the only possible 

     means   of   retaining   the   support   of   the   peasants。    There   was   a   tacit 

recognition   that   the   Conference   represented   town   workers   only。         Larin�察�

who had belonged to the old school which had grown up with its eyes on 

the industrial countries of the West and believed that revolution could be 

brought   about   by   the   town   workers   alone�察  �that   it   was   exclusively   their 

affair�察�and that all else was of minor importance�察�unguardedly spoke of the 

peasant as ;our neighbor。; In Javoslavl�察�country and town are too near to 

allow the main problem of the revolution to be thus easily dismissed。                      It 

was instantly  pointed out   that   the relation   was   much more  intimate�察 �and 

that�察�even if it were only ;neighborly�察─�peace could not long be preserved 

if it were continually necessary for one neighbor to steal the chic
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��