梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
country interrupted a play to hammer home truths about the need of work
into an audience of working men who had gathered solely for the purpose
of legitimate recreation。 It was not as if he sugared the medicine he gave
them。 His speech was nothing but demands for discipline and work�察�
coupled with prophecy of disaster in case work and discipline failed。 It
was delivered like all his speeches�察 �with a strong Polish accent and a
steady succession of mistakes in grammar。
40
´ Page 41´
THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA
As we walked home along the railway lines�察 �half a dozen of the
railwaymen pressed around Radek�察�and almost fought with each other as
to who should walk next to him。 And Radek entirely happy�察�delighted at
his success in
giving them a bombshell instead of a bouquet�察�with one stout fellow on
one arm�察 �another on the other�察 �two or three more listening in front and
behind�察�continued rubbing it into them until we reached our wagon�察�when�察�
after a general handshaking�察�they disappeared into the night。
THE TRADE UNIONS
Trade Unions in Russia are in a different position from that which is
common to all other Trades Unions in the world。 In other countries the
Trades Unions are a force with whose opposition the Government must
reckon。 In Russia the Government reckons not on the possible
opposition of the Trades Unions�察�but on their help for realizing its most
difficult measures�察�and for undermining and overwhelming any opposition
which those measures may encounter。 The Trades Unions in Russia�察�
instead of being an organization outside the State protecting the interests
of a class against the governing class�察 �have become a part of the State
organization。 Since�察 �during the present period of the revolution the
backbone of the State organization is the Communist Party�察 �the Trade
Unions have come to be practically an extension of the party organization。
This�察�of course�察�would be indignantly denied both by Trade Unionists and
Communists。 Still�察 �in the preface to the All´Russian Trades Union
Reports for 1919�察 �Glebov�察 �one of the best´known Trade Union leaders
whom I remember in the spring of last year objecting to the use of
bourgeois specialists in their proper places�察 �admits as much in the
following muddleheaded statement�此�
;The base of the proletarian dictatorship is the Communist Party�察�
which in general directs all the political and economic work of the State�察�
leaning�察�first of all�察�on the Soviets as on the more revolutionary form of
dictatorship of the proletariat�察 �and secondly on the Trades Unions�察 �as
41
´ Page 42´
THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA
organizations which economically unite the proletariat of factory and
workshop as the vanguard of the revolution�察 �and as organizations of the
new socialistic construction of the State。 Thus the Trade Unions must be
considered as a base of the Soviet State�察 �as an organic form
complementary to the other forms of the Proletariat Dictatorship。; These
two elaborate sentences constitute an admission of what I have just said。
Trades Unionists of other countries must regard the fate of their
Russian colleagues with horror or with satisfaction�察 �according to their
views of events in Russia taken as a whole。 If they do not believe that
there has been a social revolution in Russia�察�they must regard the present
position of the Russian Trades Unions as the reward of a complete defeat
of Trade Unionism�察�in which a Capitalist government has been able to lay
violent hands on the organization which was protecting the workers
against it。 If�察�on the other hand�察�they believe that there has been a social
revolution�察�so that the class organized in Trades Unions is now�察�identical
with the governing�察 �class ��of employers�察 �etc。�� against which the unions
once struggled�察�then they must regard the present position as a natural and
satisfactory result of victory。
When I was in Moscow in the spring of this year the Russian Trades
Unions received a telegram from the Trades Union Congress at
Amsterdam�察 �a telegram which admirably illustrated the impossibility of
separating judgment of the present position of the Unions from judgments
of the Russian revolution as a whole。 It encouraged the Unions ;in their
struggle; and promised support in that struggle。 The Communists
immediately asked ;What struggle�拭�Against the capitalist system in Russia
which does not exist�拭 �Or against capitalist systems outside Russia�拭─�
They said that either the telegram meant this latter only�察�or it meant that its
writers did not believe that there had been a social revolution in Russia。
The point is arguable。 If one believes that revolution is an impossibility�察�
one can reason from that belief and say that in spite of certain upheavals in
Russia the fundamental arrangement of society is the same there as in
other countries�察�so that the position of the Trade Unions there must be the
same�察�and�察�as in other countries they must be still engaged in augmenting
the dinners of their members at the expense of the dinners of the capitalists
42
´ Page 43´
THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA
which�察�in the long run ��if that were possible�� they would abolish。 If�察�on
the other hand�察�one believes that social revolution has actually occurred�察�to
speak of Trades Unions continuing the struggle in which they conquered
something like three years
ago�察 �is to urge them to a sterile fanaticism which has been neatly
described by Professor Santayana as a redoubling of your effort when you
have forgotten your aim。
It 's probably true that the ;aim; of the Trades Unions was more
clearly defined in Russia than elsewhere。 In England during the greater
part of their history the Trades Unions have not been in conscious
opposition to the State。 In Russia this p