嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
敬響嶄猟利 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

the crisis in russia(躯忽裡字)-及20嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




matter 

     properly   thrashed       out�察 �though     feeling   upon    it  is  extremely   strong。 

Everybody whom I asked about it began at once to address me as if I were 

a public meeting�察�so that I found it extremely difficult to get from either 

side a statement not free from electioneering bias。                 I think�察�however�察�that 

it may be fairly said that all but a few lunatics have abandoned the ideas of 

1917�察�which resulted in the workmen in a factory deposing any technical 

expert or manager whose orders were in the least irksome to them。                       These 

ideas and the miseries and unfairness they caused�察�the stoppages of work�察�

the    managers      sewn     up   in   sacks�察  �ducked      in  ponds     and    trundled    in 

wheelbarrows�察       �have    taken    their  places    as   curiosities   of   history。    The 

change      in   these    ideas   has    been    gradual。      The     first  step    was    the 

recognition   that   the   State   as   a   whole   was   interested   in   the   efficiency   of 

each factory�察�and�察�therefore�察�that the workmen of each factory had no right 

to arrange things with no thought except for themselves。                    The Committee 

idea was still strong�察�and the difficulty was got over by assuring that the 

technical     staff   should    be  represented      on   the  Committee�察      �and   that   the 

casting   vote   between   workers   and   technical   experts   or   managers   should 

belong to the central   economic organ   of the   State。              The   next stage   was 

when the management of a workshop was given a so called ;collegiate; 

character�察     �the    workmen         appointing      representatives       to    share     the 

responsibility of the ;bourgeois specialist。;               The bitter controversy now 

going   on   concerns   the   seemingly  inevitable   transition   to   a   later  stage   in 

which�察     �for   all  practical     purposes�察    �the   bourgeois      specialist    will    be 

responsible   solely   to   the   State。    Many   Communists�察  �including   some   of 

the   best   known�察  �while   recognizing   the   need   of   greater   efficiency   if   the 

revolution is to survive at all�察�regard this step as definitely retrograde and 

likely      in    the    long     run     to    make      the    revolution       not    worth 

preserving。*�В�*��Thus Rykov�察�President of the Supreme Council of Public 

Economy�此 �There is a possibility of so constructing a State that in it there 

will    be   a  ruling   caste    consisting    chiefly    of   administrative      engineers�察�

technicians�察�etc。�察�that is�察�we should get a form of State economy based on 



                                                 48 


´ Page 49´

                                   THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



a small group of a ruling caste whose privilege in this case would be the 

management   of   the   workersand   peasants。;           That   criticism   of   individual 

control�察  �from   a   communist�察  �goes   a   good   deal   further   than   most   of   the 

criticism      from     people     avowedly      in    opposition。�А      �The      enormous 

importance       attached    by    everybody      to  this  question     of   individual    or 

collegiate control�察�may bejudged from the fact that at every conference I 

attended�察�and every discussion to which 

     I   listened�察   �this  point�察   �which     might    seem     of  minor     importance�察�

completely overshadowed the question of industrial conscription which�察�at 

least inside the Communist Party�察�seemed generally taken for granted。                       It 

may be taken now as certain that the majority of the Communists are in 

favor     of  individual     control。    They     say    that  the   object   of   ;workers' 

control; before the revolution was to ensure that factories should be run in 

the interests of workers as well of employers。              In Russia now there are no 

employers other than the State as a whole�察�which is exclusively made up 

of employees。 ��I am stating now the view of the majority at the last Trades 

Union   Congress   at   which   I   was   present�察  �April�察  �1920。��        They   say   that 

;workers' control; exists in a larger and more efficient manner than was 

suggested       by   the   old   pre´revolutionary      statements      on   that   question。 

Further�察�they say that if workers' control ought to be identified with Trade 

Union      control�察  �the   Trades    Unions     are  certainly    supreme     in  all  those 

matters   with   which   they   have   chiefly   concerned   themselves�察  �since   they 

dominate the Commissariat of Labor�察�are very largely represented on the 

Supreme   Council   of   Public   Economy�察  �and   fix   the   rates   of   pay   for   their 

own   members。*�В�*��The   wages   of   workmen   are   decided   by   the   Trades 

Unions�察     �who    draw    up    ;tariffs;   for  the   whole     country�察   �basing    their 

calculations on three criteria�此。�I�� The price of food in the open market in 

the district where a workman is employed�察。�2��the price of food supplied by 

the State on the card system�察。�3��the quality of the workman。 This last is 

decided   by   a   special   section   of   the   Factory   Committee�察  �which   in   each 

factory is an organ of the Trades Union。�А�

       The    enormous      Communist        majority�察   �together    with    the  fact   that 

however   much   they   may   quarrel   with   each   other   inside   the   party�察  �the 

Communists   will   go   to   almost   any   length   to   avoid   breaking   the   party 



                                                49 


´ Page 50´

                                   THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



discipline�察     �means     that   at   present    the    resolutions     of   Trades     Union 

Congresses will not be different from those of Communists Congresses on 

the same subjects。         Consequently�察�the questions which really agitate the 

members�察       �the   actual   cleavages      inside    that  Communist        majority�察    �are 

comparatively   invisible   at   a   Trades   Union   Congress。           They   are   fought 

over with great bitterness�察�but they are not fought over in the Hall of the 

Unions´once the Club of the Nobility�察�with on its walls on Congress days 

the   hammer   and   spanner   of   the   engineers�察  �the   pestle   and   trowel   of   the 

builders�察�and so on´but in the Communist 

     Congresses   in   the   Kremlin   and   throughout   the   country。   And�察  �in   the 

problem   with   which   in   this   book   we   are   mainly   concerned�察  �neither   the 

regular   business   of   the   Unions   nor   their   internal   squabbles   affects   the 

cardinal     fact   that  in  the   present    crisis   the  Trades    Unions     are   chiefly 

important      as   part  of   that  organization      of  human     will   with    which    the 

C
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��