嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
敬響嶄猟利 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

alexandria and her schools(冉煽表寄才慢議僥丕)-及21嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




Alexandria       would    have    astonished     Plotinus    or   Hypatia    as   much    as   it 

would   Clement   or   Origen。        I   do   not   say  that   there is�察 �or   ought   to   be�察  �a 

Christian Metaphysic。          I am speaking�察�as you know�察�merely as a historian�察�

dealing with facts�察�and I say that there was one�察�as profound�察�as scientific�察�

as   severe�察  �as   that   of   the   Pagan   Neoplatonists�察  �starting   indeed�察  �as   I   shall 

show hereafter�察�on many points from common ground with theirs。                            One 

can hardly doubt�察�I should fancy�察�that many parts of St。 John's Gospel and 

Epistles�察  �whatever   view   we   may   take   of   them�察  �if   they   are   to   be   called 

anything�察�are to be called metaphysic and philosophic。                     And one can no 

more     doubt    that   before    writing    them    he   had   studied    Philo�察  �and   was 

expanding Philo's thought in the direction which seemed fit to him�察�than 

we   can   doubt   it   of   the   earlier   Neoplatonists。   The   technical   language   is 

often identical�察�so are the primary ideas from which he starts�察�howsoever 

widely   the   conclusions   may   differ。        If   Plotinus   considered   himself   an 



                                                 50 


´ Page 51´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



intellectual disciple of Plato�察�so did Origen and Clemens。                 And I must�察�as 

I   said   before�察  �speak   of   both�察  �or   of   neither。 My   only   hope   of   escaping 

delicate ground lies in the curious fact�察�that rightly or wrongly�察�the form in 

which Christianity presented itself to the old Alexandrian thinkers was so 

utterly different from the popular conception of it in modern England�察�that 

one may very likely be able to tell what little one knows about it�察�almost 

without mentioning a single doctrine which now influences the religious 

world。 

     But far greater is my fear�察�that to a modern British auditory�察�trained in 

the school of Locke�察�much of ancient thought�察�heathen as well as Christian�察�

may seem so utterly the product of the imagination�察�so utterly without any 

corresponding   reality  in   the   universe�察  �as   to   look   like   mere   unintelligible 

madness。       Still�察  �I   must   try�察  �only  entreating   my  hearers   to   consider�察  �that 

how much soever we may honour Locke and his great Scotch followers�察�

we   are   not   bound   to   believe   them   either   infallible�察  �or   altogether   world´ 

embracing�察�that there have been other methods than theirs of conceiving 

the   Unseen�察    �that   the  common       ground    from   which     both   Christian    and 

heathen Alexandrians start�察�is not merely a private vagary of their own�察�but 

one which has been accepted undoubtingly�察�under so many various forms�察�

by    so   many     different    races�察  �as  to   give   something      of   an   inductive 

probability that it is not a mere dream�察�but may be a right and true instinct 

of   the   human   mind。     I   mean   the   belief   that   the   things   which   we   see 

nature and all her phenomena are temporal�察�and born only to die�察�mere 

shadows   of   some   unseen   realities�察  �from   whom   their   laws   and   life   are 

derived�察�while the eternal things which subsist without growth�察�decay�察�or 

change�察�the only real�察�only truly existing things�察�in short�察�are certain things 

which      are   not   seen�察   �inappreciable      by    sense�察  �or   understanding�察      �or 

imagination�察�perceived only by the conscience and the reason。                     And that�察�

again�察�the problem of philosophy�察�the highest good for man�察�that for the 

sake    of   which    death   were    a  gain�察  �without    which    life  is  worthless�察   �a 

drudgery�察  �a   degradation�察  �a   failure�察  �and   a   ruin�察  �is   to   discover   what   those 

unseen eternal things are�察�to know them�察�possess them�察�be in harmony with 

them�察�and thereby alone to rise to any real and solid power�察�or safety�察�or 

nobleness。      It is a strange dream。         But you will see that it is one which 



                                                51 


´ Page 52´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



does    not   bear   much     upon    ;points   of  controversy�察─     �any   more    than   on 

;Locke's philosophy�察─�nevertheless�察�when we find this same strange dream 

arising�察  �apparently   without   intercommunion   of   thought�察  �among   the   old 

Hindoos�察�among the Greeks�察�among the Jews�察�and lastly�察�when we see it 

springing   again   in   the   Middle Age�察  �in   the   mind   of   the   almost   forgotten 

author   of   the   ;Deutsche   Theologie�察─  �and   so   becoming   the   parent�察         �not 

merely of Luther's deepest belief�察�or of the German mystic schools of the 

seventeenth and eighteenth centuries�察�but of the great German Philosophy 

itself as developed by Kant�察�and Fichte�察�and Schelling�察�and Hegel�察�we must 

at least confess it to be a popular delusion�察�if nothing better�察�vast enough 

and common enough to be worth a little patient investigation�察�wheresoever 

we may find it stirring the human mind。 

     But   I   have   hope�察  �still�察  �that   I   may  find   sympathy  and   comprehension 

among some�察�at least�察�of my audience�察�as I proceed to examine the ancient 

realist schools of Alexandria�察�on account of their knowledge of the modern 

realist   schools   of   Germany。      For   I   cannot   but   see�察  �that   a   revulsion   is 

taking place in the thoughts of our nation upon metaphysic subjects�察�and 

that Scotland�察�as usual�察�is taking the lead therein。               That most illustrious 

Scotchman�察       �Mr。   Thomas      Carlyle�察    �first  vindicated     the   great   German 

Realists     from    the  vulgar    misconceptions        about   them    which     were    so 

common        at  the  beginning     of   this  century�察   �and   brought    the   minds    of 

studious men to a more just appreciation of the philosophic severity�察�the 

moral grandeur�察�of such thinkers as Emmanuel Kant�察�and Gottlieb Fichte。 

To   another   Scotch   gentleman�察  �who�察  �I   believe�察  �has   honoured   me   by   his 

presence   here   to´night�察  �we   owe   most   valuable   translations   of   some   of 

Fichte's works�察�to be followed�察�I trust�察�by more。             And though�察�as a humble 

disciple   of   Bacon�察  �I   cannot   but   think   that   the   method   both   of   Kant   and 

Fichte possesses somewhat of the same inherent defect as the method of 

the Neoplatonist school�察�yet I should be most unfair did I not express my 

deep obligations to them�察�and advise all those to study them carefully�察�who 

wish to gain a clear conception either of the old Alexandrian schools�察�or of 

those   intellectual   movements   which   are   agitating   the   modern   mind�察  �and 

which will�察�I doubt not�察�issue in a clearer light�察�and in a nobler life�察�if not 

for us�察�yet
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��