嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
敬響嶄猟利 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

russia in 1919(1919議躯忽)-及38嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




actually     have    all  power    instead    of  merely     supporting     the  Bolshevik 

bureaucracy。       He was asked for his own programme�察�but said he had not 

time     to   give    it。    I    watched      the    applause     carefully。      General 

dissatisfaction with the present state of affairs was obvious�察�but it was also 

obvious   that   no   party   would   have   a   chance   that   admitted   its   aim   was 

extinction of the Soviets ��which Dan's ultimate aim certainly is�察�or at least 

the   changing   of   them   into   non´political   industrial   organizations��   or   that 

was not prepared to fight against reaction from without。 

       I went to see Sukhanov ��the friend of Gorky and Martov�察�though his 

political opinions do not precisely agree with those of either���察�partly to get 

the proofs of his first volume of reminiscences of the revolution�察�partly to 

hear what he had to say。          I found him muffled up in a dressing gown or 

overcoat in an unheated flat�察�sitting down to tea with no sugar�察�very little 

bread�察   �a  little  sausage    and   a  surprising    scrap   of  butter�察  �brought    in�察 �I 

suppose�察�from the country by a friend。              Nikitsky�察�a Menshevik�察�was also 

there�察�a hopeless figure�察�prophesying the rotting of the whole system and 

of the revolution。       Sukhanov asked me if I had noticed the disappearance 

of all spoons ��there are now none�察�but wooden spoons in the Metropole�� as 

a symbol of the falling to pieces of the revolution。              I told him that though 

I had not lived in Russia thirty years or more�察�as he had�察�I had yet lived 

there long enough and had�察�before the revolution�察�sufficient experience in 


´ Page 112´

                                        RUSSIA IN 1919 



the loss of fishing tackle�察�not to be surprised that Russian peasants�察�even 

delegates�察�when able�察�as in such a moment of convulsion as the revolution�察�

stole   spoons   if   only   as   souvenirs   to   show   that   they   had   really   been   to 

Moscow。 

       We talked�察�of course�察�of their attitude towards the Bolsheviks。                Both 

work in Soviet institutions。         Sukhanov ��Nikitsky agreeing�� believed that 

if the Bolsheviks came further to meet the other parties�察�Mensheviks�察�etc。�察�

;Kolchak      and   Denikin     would    commit   suicide     and   your   Lloyd    George 

would give up all thought of intervention。; I asked�察�What if they should be 

told   to   hold   a   Constituent   Assembly   or   submit   to   a   continuance   of   the 

blockade�拭     �Sukhanov       said�察  �Such     a  Constituent     Assembly      would     be 

impossible�察�and we should be against it。; Of the Soviets�察�one or other said�察�

;We stand absolutely on the platform of the Soviet Government now�此�but 

we think that such a form cannot be permanent。                We consider the Soviets 

perfect     instruments      of  class    struggle�察   �but   not   a   perfect    form    of 

government。; I asked Sukhanov if he thought counter revolution possible。 

He said ;No�察─�but admitted that there was a danger lest the agitation of the 

Mensheviks or others might set fire to the discontent of the masses against 

the actual physical conditions�察�and end in pogroms destroying Bolsheviks 

and Mensheviks alike。          Their general theory was that Russia was not so 

far   developed      that  a  Socialist    State   was   at  present    possible。     They 

therefore wanted a state in which private capital should exist�察�and in which 

factories    were    not  run   by   the  state  but   by   individual    owners。     They 

believed that   the  peasants�察 �with their  instincts  of small   property´holders�察�

would eventually enforce something of the kind�察�and that the end would be 

some form of democratic Republic。              These two were against the offering 

of concessions to the Allies�察�on the ground that those under consideration 

involved   the   handing   over  to   the   concessionaires of   the  whole  power  in 

northern     Russia´railways�察�forests�察�the right to set up their own banks in 

the towns served by the railway�察�with all that this implied。 Sukhanov was 

against concessions on principle�察�and regretted that the Mensheviks were 

in favour of them。 

       I   saw   Martov   at   the   offices   of   his   newspaper�察  �which   had   just   been 

suppressed      on   account    of   an  article�察 �which     he  admitted     was   a  little 


´ Page 113´

                                          RUSSIA IN 1919 



indiscreet�察�objecting   to  the upkeep of   the   Red Army  ��see   page   167��。   He 

pointed eloquently to the seal on some of the doors�察�but told me that he 

had started a new paper�察�of which he showed me the first number�察�and told 

me that the demand for it was such that although he had intended that it 

should be a weekly he now expected to make it a daily。                     Martov said that 

he and his party were against every form of intervention for the following 

reasons�此  �1。   The   continuation   of   hostilities�察  �the   need   of   an   army   and   of 

active defence were bound to intensify the least desirable qualities of the 

revolution      whereas      an   agreement�察      �by   lessening     the    tension�察   �would 

certainly lead to moderation of Bolshevik Policy。 2。 The needs of the army 

overwhelmed every effort at restoring the economic life of the country。 He 

was   further   convinced   that   intervention   of   any   kind   favoured   reaction�察�

even   supposing   that   the   Allies   did   not   wish      this。   ;They   cannot      help 

themselves�察─�he said�察 �the forces that would support intervention must be 

dominated by those of reaction�察�since all of the non´reactionary parties are 

prepared to sink their differences with the Bolsheviks�察�in order to defend 

the revolution as a whole。; He said he was convinced that the Bolsheviks 

would   either   have   to   alter   or   go。  He   read   me�察  �in   illustration   of   this�察  �a 

letter from a peasant showing the unreadiness of the peasantry to go into 

communes ��compulsion in this matter has already been discarded by the 

Central   Government��。          ;We   took   the   land�察─  �wrote   the   peasant   in   some 

such words�察 �not much�察�just   as much as we  could work�察�we ploughed   it 

where   it   had   not   been   ploughed   before�察  �and   now�察  �if   it   is   made   into   a 

commune�察  �other   lazy   fellows   who   have   done   nothing   will   come   in   and 

profit by our work。; Martov argued that life itself�察�the needs of the country 

and the will of the peasant masses�察 �would lead   to the  changes he   thinks 

desirable in the Soviet regime。 


´ Page 114´

                                        RUSSIA IN 1919 



                     THE RIGHT SOCIAL 

                  REVOLUTIONARIES 



       The   position   of   the   Right   Social  Revolutionaries   is   a   good   deal 

more complicate
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��