嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
敬響嶄猟利 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

proposed roads to freedom(宥吏徭喇岻揃)-及13嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




period�察�he became a Hegelian�察�and in 1840 he went to Berlin to continue 

his studies�察�in the hope of ultimately becoming a professor。 But after this 

time   his   opinions   underwent   a   rapid   change。   He   found   it   impossible   to 

accept the   Hegelian   maxim  that   whatever   is�察 �is   rational�察  �and   in   1842   he 

migrated to Dresden�察�where he became associated with Arnold Ruge�察�the 

publisher      of  ``Deutsche      Jahrbuecher。''     By    this  time   he   had    become     a 

revolutionary�察  �and   in   the   following   year   he   incurred   the   hostility   of   the 

Saxon Government。 This led him to go to Switzerland�察�where he came in 

contact   with   a   group   of   German   Communists�察  �but�察  �as   the   Swiss   police 

importuned   him   and   the   Russian   Government   demanded   his   return�察  �he 

removed to Paris�察�where he remained from 1843 to 1847。 These years in 

Paris   were   important   in   the   formation   of   his   outlook   and   opinions。   He 

became       acquainted       with    Proudhon�察      �who      exercised     a    considerable 

influence   on   him�察  �also   with   George   Sand   and   many   other   well´   known 

people。  It   was   in   Paris   that   he   first   made   the   acquaintance   of   Marx   and 

Engels�察�with whom he was to carry on a lifelong battle。 At a much later 

period�察�in 1871�察�he gave the following account of his relations with Marx 

at this time�此�

        Marx was much more advanced than I was�察�as he remains to´day not 

more   advanced   but   incomparably   more   learned   than   I   am。   I   knew   then 

nothing   of   political   economy。   I   had   not   yet   rid   myself   of   metaphysical 

abstractions�察�and my Socialism was only instinctive。 He�察�though younger 

than I�察�was already an atheist�察�an instructed materialist�察�a well´considered 

Socialist。 It was just at this time that he elaborated the first foundations of 



                                                  31 


´ Page 32´

                             PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM 



his   present   system。   We   saw   each   other   fairly   often�察  �for   I   respected   him 

much   for   his   learning   and   his   passionate   and   serious   devotion   ��always 

mixed�察�however�察�with personal vanity�� to the cause of the proletariat�察�and I 

sought eagerly his conversation�察�which was always instructive and clever�察�

when it was not inspired by a paltry hate�察�which�察�alas� �happened only too 

often。     But    there   was    never     any   frank    intimacy      between     as。   Our 

temperaments would not suffer it。 He called me a sentimental idealist�察�and 

he was right�察�I called him a vain man�察�perfidious and crafty�察�and I also was 

right。 

       Bakunin      never    succeeded     in   staying    long   in  one    place   without 

incurring the enmity of the authorities。 In November�察�1847�察�as the result of 

a speech praising the Polish rising of 1830�察�he was expelled from France at 

the request of the Russian Embassy�察�which�察�in order to rob him of public 

sympathy�察�spread the   unfounded report that he had been an   agent of the 

Russian Government�察�but was no longer wanted because he had gone too 

far。   The   French     Government�察      �by   calculated    reticence�察  �encouraged      this 

story�察�which clung to him more or less throughout his life。 

     Being     compelled      to  leave   France�察   �he   went   to   Brussels�察   �where    he 

renewed   acquaintance   with   Marx。   A   letter   of   his�察  �written   at   this   time�察�

shows that he entertained already that bitter hatred for which afterward he 

had    so   much     reason。    ``The    Germans�察     �artisans�察  �Bornstedt�察    �Marx    and 

Engelsand�察  �above        all�察  �Marxare   here�察  �doing   their   ordinary   mischief。 

Vanity�察     �spite�察   �gossip�察     �theoretical     overbearingness         and     practical 

pusillanimityreflections         on   life�察 �action   and   simplicity�察   �and   complete 

absence of life�察�action and simplicityliterary and argumentative artisans 

and   repulsive   coquetry   with   them�此   �Feuerbach   is   a   bourgeois��'   and   the 

word `bourgeois' grown into an epithet and repeated ad nauseum�察�but all of 

them     themselves      from    head   to  foot�察  �through     and   through�察   �provincial 

bourgeois。 With one word�察�lying and stupidity�察�stupidity and lying。 In this 

society there is no possibility of drawing a free�察�full breath。 I hold myself 

aloof   from   them�察  �and   have   declared   quite   decidedly   that   I   will   not   join 

their communistic union of artisans�察�and will have nothing to do with it。'' 

     The   Revolution       of  1848    led   him   to  return   to  Paris   and   thence   to 

Germany。 He had a quarrel with Marx over a matter in which he himself 



                                                32 


´ Page 33´

                             PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM 



confessed later   that   Marx   was   in   the   right。   He   became   a   member   of   the 

Slav Congress in Prague�察�where he vainly endeavored to promote a Slav 

insurrection。   Toward   the   end   of   1848�察  �he   wrote   an   ``Appeal   to   Slavs��'' 

calling on them to combine with other revolutionaries to destroy the three 

oppressive monarchies�察�Russia�察�Austria and Prussia。 Marx attacked him in 

print�察  �saying�察  �in   effect�察  �that   the   movement   for   Bohemian   independence 

was   futile   because   the   Slavs   had   no   future�察  �at   any   rate   in   those   regions 

where   they   hap´   pened   to   be   subject   to   Germany   and Austria。   Bakunin 

accused Mars of German patriotism in this matter�察�and Marx accused him 

of Pan´Slavism�察�no doubt in both cases justly。 Before this dispute�察�however�察�

a   much   more   serious   quarrel   had   taken   place。   Marx's   paper�察  �the   ``Neue 

Rheinische Zeitung��'' stated that George Sand had papers proving Bakunin 

to   be   a   Russian   Government   agent   and   one   of   those   responsible   for   the 

recent   arrest   of   Poles。   Bakunin�察  �of   course�察  �repudiated   the   charge�察  �and 

George      Sand    wrote    to  the   ``Neue    Rheinische      Zeitung��''   denying     this 

statement in   toto。 The   denials were published by  Marx�察�and   there   was   a 

nominal reconciliation�察�but from this time onward there was never any real 

abatement of the hostility between these rival leaders�察�who did not meet 

again until 1864。 

     Meanwhile�察�the reaction had been everywhere gaining ground。 In May�察�

1849�察�an insurrection in Dresden for a moment made the revolutionaries 

masters     of   the   town。    They    held   it  for  five   days    and   established     a 

revolutionary   government。   Bakunin   was   the   soul   of   the   defense   which 

they made against the Prussian troops。 But they were overpowered�察�and at 

last   Bakunin     was    captured    while    trying   to  escape    with   He
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��