梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
period�察�he became a Hegelian�察�and in 1840 he went to Berlin to continue
his studies�察�in the hope of ultimately becoming a professor。 But after this
time his opinions underwent a rapid change。 He found it impossible to
accept the Hegelian maxim that whatever is�察 �is rational�察 �and in 1842 he
migrated to Dresden�察�where he became associated with Arnold Ruge�察�the
publisher of ``Deutsche Jahrbuecher。'' By this time he had become a
revolutionary�察 �and in the following year he incurred the hostility of the
Saxon Government。 This led him to go to Switzerland�察�where he came in
contact with a group of German Communists�察 �but�察 �as the Swiss police
importuned him and the Russian Government demanded his return�察 �he
removed to Paris�察�where he remained from 1843 to 1847。 These years in
Paris were important in the formation of his outlook and opinions。 He
became acquainted with Proudhon�察 �who exercised a considerable
influence on him�察 �also with George Sand and many other well´ known
people。 It was in Paris that he first made the acquaintance of Marx and
Engels�察�with whom he was to carry on a lifelong battle。 At a much later
period�察�in 1871�察�he gave the following account of his relations with Marx
at this time�此�
Marx was much more advanced than I was�察�as he remains to´day not
more advanced but incomparably more learned than I am。 I knew then
nothing of political economy。 I had not yet rid myself of metaphysical
abstractions�察�and my Socialism was only instinctive。 He�察�though younger
than I�察�was already an atheist�察�an instructed materialist�察�a well´considered
Socialist。 It was just at this time that he elaborated the first foundations of
31
´ Page 32´
PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM
his present system。 We saw each other fairly often�察 �for I respected him
much for his learning and his passionate and serious devotion ��always
mixed�察�however�察�with personal vanity�� to the cause of the proletariat�察�and I
sought eagerly his conversation�察�which was always instructive and clever�察�
when it was not inspired by a paltry hate�察�which�察�alas� �happened only too
often。 But there was never any frank intimacy between as。 Our
temperaments would not suffer it。 He called me a sentimental idealist�察�and
he was right�察�I called him a vain man�察�perfidious and crafty�察�and I also was
right。
Bakunin never succeeded in staying long in one place without
incurring the enmity of the authorities。 In November�察�1847�察�as the result of
a speech praising the Polish rising of 1830�察�he was expelled from France at
the request of the Russian Embassy�察�which�察�in order to rob him of public
sympathy�察�spread the unfounded report that he had been an agent of the
Russian Government�察�but was no longer wanted because he had gone too
far。 The French Government�察 �by calculated reticence�察 �encouraged this
story�察�which clung to him more or less throughout his life。
Being compelled to leave France�察 �he went to Brussels�察 �where he
renewed acquaintance with Marx。 A letter of his�察 �written at this time�察�
shows that he entertained already that bitter hatred for which afterward he
had so much reason。 ``The Germans�察 �artisans�察 �Bornstedt�察 �Marx and
Engelsand�察 �above all�察 �Marxare here�察 �doing their ordinary mischief。
Vanity�察 �spite�察 �gossip�察 �theoretical overbearingness and practical
pusillanimityreflections on life�察 �action and simplicity�察 �and complete
absence of life�察�action and simplicityliterary and argumentative artisans
and repulsive coquetry with them�此 �Feuerbach is a bourgeois��' and the
word `bourgeois' grown into an epithet and repeated ad nauseum�察�but all of
them themselves from head to foot�察 �through and through�察 �provincial
bourgeois。 With one word�察�lying and stupidity�察�stupidity and lying。 In this
society there is no possibility of drawing a free�察�full breath。 I hold myself
aloof from them�察 �and have declared quite decidedly that I will not join
their communistic union of artisans�察�and will have nothing to do with it。''
The Revolution of 1848 led him to return to Paris and thence to
Germany。 He had a quarrel with Marx over a matter in which he himself
32
´ Page 33´
PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM
confessed later that Marx was in the right。 He became a member of the
Slav Congress in Prague�察�where he vainly endeavored to promote a Slav
insurrection。 Toward the end of 1848�察 �he wrote an ``Appeal to Slavs��''
calling on them to combine with other revolutionaries to destroy the three
oppressive monarchies�察�Russia�察�Austria and Prussia。 Marx attacked him in
print�察 �saying�察 �in effect�察 �that the movement for Bohemian independence
was futile because the Slavs had no future�察 �at any rate in those regions
where they hap´ pened to be subject to Germany and Austria。 Bakunin
accused Mars of German patriotism in this matter�察�and Marx accused him
of Pan´Slavism�察�no doubt in both cases justly。 Before this dispute�察�however�察�
a much more serious quarrel had taken place。 Marx's paper�察 �the ``Neue
Rheinische Zeitung��'' stated that George Sand had papers proving Bakunin
to be a Russian Government agent and one of those responsible for the
recent arrest of Poles。 Bakunin�察 �of course�察 �repudiated the charge�察 �and
George Sand wrote to the ``Neue Rheinische Zeitung��'' denying this
statement in toto。 The denials were published by Marx�察�and there was a
nominal reconciliation�察�but from this time onward there was never any real
abatement of the hostility between these rival leaders�察�who did not meet
again until 1864。
Meanwhile�察�the reaction had been everywhere gaining ground。 In May�察�
1849�察�an insurrection in Dresden for a moment made the revolutionaries
masters of the town。 They held it for five days and established a
revolutionary government。 Bakunin was the soul of the defense which
they made against the Prussian troops。 But they were overpowered�察�and at
last Bakunin was captured while trying to escape with He