梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
more recent years�察 �and thence to the Syndicalist revolt against Socialist
emphasis on the State and political action�察 �and to certain movements
outside France which have some affinity with Syndicalism notably the I。
W。 W。 in America and Guild Socialism in England。 From this historical
survey we shall pass to the consideration of some of the more pressing
problems of the future�察�and shall try to decide in what respects the world
would be happier if the aims of Socialists or Syndicalists were achieved。
My own opinionwhich I may as well indicate at the outsetis that
pure Anarchism�察�though it should be the ultimate ideal�察�to which society
should continually approximate�察�is for the present impossible�察�and would
not survive more than a year or two at most if it were adopted。 On the
other hand�察 �both Marxian Socialism and Syndicalism�察 �in spite of many
drawbacks�察 �seem to me calculated to give rise to a happier and better
world than that in which we live。 I do not�察�however�察�regard either of them
as the best practicable system。 Marxian Socialism�察�I fear�察�would give far
too much power to the State�察�while Syndicalism�察�which aims at abolishing
the State�察 �would�察 �I believe�察 �find itself forced to reconstruct a central
authority in order to put an end to the rivalries of different groups of
producers。 The BEST practicable system�察 �to my mind�察 �is that of Guild
Socialism�察 �which concedes what is valid both in the claims of the State
Socialists and in the Syndicalist fear of the State�察�by adopting a system of
federalism among trades for reasons similar to those which are
recommending federalism among nations。 The grounds for these
4
´ Page 5´
PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM
conclusions will appear as we proceed。
Before embarking upon the history of recent movements In favor of
radical reconstruction�察 �it will be worth while to consider some traits of
character which distinguish most political idealists�察 �and are much
misunderstood by the general public for other reasons besides mere
prejudice。 I wish to do full justice to these reasons�察�in order to show the
more effectually why they ought not to be operative。
The leaders of the more advanced movements are�察�in general�察�men of
quite unusual disinterestedness�察�as is evident from a consideration of their
careers。 Although they have obviously quite as much ability as many men
who rise to positions of great power�察�they do not themselves become the
arbiters of contemporary events�察 �nor do they achieve wealth or the
applause of the mass of their contemporaries。 Men who have the capacity
for winning these prizes�察�and who work at least as hard as those who win
them�察 �but deliberately adopt a line which makes the winning of them
impossible�察 �must be judged to have an aim in life other than personal
advancement�察�whatever admixture of self´seeking may enter into the detail
of their lives�察�their fundamental motive must be outside Self。 The pioneers
of Socialism�察 �Anarchism�察 �and Syndicalism have�察 �for the most part�察�
experienced prison�察�exile�察�and poverty�察�deliberately incurred because they
would not abandon their propaganda�察�and by this conduct they have shown
that the hope which inspired them was not for themselves�察 �but for
mankind。
Nevertheless�察�though the desire for human welfare is what at bottom
determines the broad lines of such men's lives�察�it often happens that�察�in the
detail of their speech and writing�察�hatred is far more visible than love。 The
impatient idealistand without some impatience a man will hardly prove
effectiveis almost sure to be led into hatred by the oppositions and
disappointments which he encounters in his endeavors to bring happiness
to the world。 The more certain he is of the purity of his motives and the
truth of his gospel�察�the more indignant he will become when his teaching
is rejected。 Often he will successfully achieve an attitude of philosophic
tolerance as regards the apathy of the masses�察 �and even as regards the
whole´hearted opposition of professed defenders of the status quo。 But the
5
´ Page 6´
PROPOSED ROADS TO FREEDOM
men whom he finds it impossible to forgive are those who profess the
same desire for the amelioration of society as he feels himself�察�but who do
not accept his method of achieving this end。 The intense faith which
enables him to withstand persecution for the sake of his beliefs makes him
consider these beliefs so luminously obvious that any thinking man who
rejects them must be dishonest�察 �and must be actuated by some sinister
motive of treachery to the cause。 Hence arises the spirit of the sect�察�that
bitter�察�narrow orthodoxy which is the bane of those who hold strongly to
an unpopular creed。 So many real temptations to treachery exist that
suspicion is natural。 And among leaders�察�ambition�察�which they mortify in
their choice of a career�察�is sure to return in a new form�此�in the desire for
intellectual mastery and for despotic power within their own sect。 From
these causes it results that the advocates of drastic reform divide
themselves into opposing schools�察�hating each other with a bitter hatred�察�
accusing each other often of such crimes as being in the pay of the police�察�
and demanding�察�of any speaker or writer whom they are to admire�察�that he
shall conform exactly to their prejudices�察 �and make all his teaching
minister to their belief that the exact truth is to be found within the limits
of their creed。 The result of this state of mind is that�察 �to a casual and
unimaginative attention�察 �the men who have sacrificed most through the
wish to benefit mankind APPEAR to be actuated far more by hatred than
by love。 And the demand for orthodoxy is stifling to any free exercise of
intellect。 This cause�察�as well as economic prejudice�察�has made it difficult
for the ``intellectuals'' to co´operate prac´ tically with the more extreme
reformers�察 �however they may sympathize with their main purposes an