梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
chooses to enact�察�is of the nature of violence rather than of law�拭�
To be sure ��answered Pericles���察 �adding�此�At your age we were clever
hands at such quibbles ourselves。 It was just such subtleties which we used
to practise our wits upon�察�as you do now�察�if I mistake not。
To which Alcibiades replied�此�Ah�察 �Pericles�察 �I do wish we could have
met in those days when you were at your cleverest in such matters。
Well�察�then�察�as soon as the desired superiority over the politicians of the
day seemed to be attained�察 �Critias and Alcibiades turned their backs on
Socrates。 They found his society unattractive�察 �not to speak of the
annoyance of being cross´questioned on their own shortcomings。
Forthwith they devoted themselves to those affairs of state but for which
they would never have come near him at all。
No�察�if one would seek to see true companions of Socrates�察�one must
look to Crito�撮�24�А�and Chaerephon�察�and Chaerecrates�察�to Hermogenes�察�to
Simmias and Cebes�察�to Phaedondes and others�察�who clung to him not to
excel in the rhetoric of the Assembly or the law´courts�察�but with the nobler
ambition of attaining to such beauty and goodliness of soul as would
enable them to discharge the various duties of life to house and family�察�to
relatives and friends�察�to fellow´citizens�察�and to the state at large。 Of these
true followers not one in youth or old age was ever guilty�察 �or thought
guilty�察�of committing any evil deed。
��24�А �For these true followers�察 �familiar to us in the pages of Plato�察�
�─�Crito�察─ �Apol。�察─ �Phaedo�察─�etc�� see Cobet�察 �Pros。 Xen。;
;But for all that�察─ �the accuser insists�察 �Socrates taught sons to pour
contumely upon their fathers��25�А�by persuading his young friends that he
could make them wiser than their sires�察 �or by pointing out that the law
allowed a son to sue his father for aberration of mind�察�and to imprison him�察�
which legal ordinance he put in evidence to prove that it might be well for
the wiser to imprison the more ignorant。;
��25�А�See ;Apol。; 20�察�Arist。 ;Clouds�察─�1407�察�where Pheidippides ;drags
18
´ Page 19´
The Memorabilia
his father Strepsiades through the mire。;
Now what Socrates held was�察 �that if a man may with justice
incarcerate another for no better cause than a form of folly or ignorance�察�
this same person could not justly complain if he in his turn were kept in
bonds by his superiors in knowledge�察�and to come to the bottom of such
questions�察�to discover the difference between madness and ignorance was
a problem which he was perpetually working at。 His opinion came to this�此�
If a madman may�察�as a matter of expediency to himself and his friends�察�be
kept in prison�察�surely�察�as a matter of justice�察�the man who knows not what
he ought to know should be content to sit at the feet of those who know�察�
and be taught。
But it was the rest of their kith and kin�察�not fathers only ��according to
the accuser���察 �whom Socrates dishonoured in the eyes of his circle of
followers�察�when he said that ;the sick man or the litigant does not derive
assistance from his relatives�撮�26�А�but from his doctor in the one case�察�and
his legal adviser in the other。; ;Listen further to his language about
friends�察─ �says the accuser�此 �'What is the good of their being kindly
disposed�察�unless they can be of some practical use to you�拭�Mere goodness
of disposition is nothing�察�those only are worthy of honour who combine
with the knowledge of what is right the faculty of expounding it��'��27�А�and
so by bringing the young to look upon himself as a superlatively wise
person gifted with an extraordinary capacity for making others wise also�察�
he so worked on the dispositions of those who consorted with him that in
their esteem the rest of the world counted for nothing by comparison with
Socrates。;
��26�А�See Grote�察 �H。 G。; v。 535。
��27�А �Cf。 Thuc。 ii。 60。 Pericles says�察 �Yet I with whom you are so
angry venture to say of myself�察 �that I am as capable as any one of
devising and explaining a sound policy。;Jowett。
Now I admit the language about fathers and the rest of a man's
relations。 I can go further�察�and add some other sayings of his�察�that ;when
the soul ��which is alone the indwelling centre of intelligence�� is gone out
of a man�察�be he our nearest and dearest friend�察�we carry the body forth and
19
´ Page 20´
The Memorabilia
bury it out of sight。; ;Even in life�察─�he used to say�察 �each of us is ready to
part with any portion of his best possessionto wit�察�his own bodyif it be
useless and unprofitable。 He will remove it himself�察�or suffer another to do
so in his stead。 Thus men cut off their own nails�察�hair�察�or corns�察�they allow
surgeons to cut and cauterise them�察�not without pains and aches�察�and are so
grateful to the doctor for his services that they further give him a fee。 Or
again�察�a man ejects the spittle from his mouth as far as possible。��28�А�Why�拭�
Because it is of no use while it stays within the system�察�but is detrimental
rather。;
��28�А�See Aristot。 ;Eth。 Eud。; vii。 1。
Now by these instances his object was not to inculcate the duty of
burying one's father alive or of cutting oneself to bits�察 �but to show that
lack of intelligence means lack of worth�撮�29�А �and so he called upon his
hearers to be as sensible and useful as they could be�察�so that�察�be it father or
brother or any one else whose esteem he would deserve�察�a man should not
hug himself in careless self´interest�察 �trusting to mere relationship�察 �but
strive to be useful to those whose esteem he coveted。
��29�А�i。e。 ;witless and worthless are synonymous。;
But ��pursues the accuser�� by carefully culling the most immoral
passages of the famous poets�察�and using them as evidences�察�he taught his
associates to be evildoers and tyrranical�此 �the line of Hesiod��30�А �for
instance
No work is a disgrace�察�slackness of work is the disgrace
;interpreted�察─�says the accuser�察 �by Socrates as if the poet enjoined us
to abstain from no work wicked or ignoble�察�do everything for the sake of
gain。;
��30�А �Works and Days�察─ �309 ��'Ergon d' ouden oneidos��。 Cf。 Plat。
;Charm。; 163 C。
Now while